Found these the same day in close proximity to eachother. Know what the I is , but can't find any info on the flag button. The word GRACE is in the diamond in the flag with backmark S. APPEL &Co. NEW YORK. Thanks to anyone with any info. Also, found what I think is an 1882 Winchester reloading tool. It is still undergoing electrolysis. Thanks.
Congrats on the nice buttons! I like digging buttons as much as old coins, the limitless variety just amazes me